Yup, I just batch froze all 6 of the channels in my example, and ended up with usable stems 😊

Reaper DEVS should have recently fixed the slowness of VST3 plugin in a beta version of Reaper as I told in the other thread.

To recap, I was already building a template with Event Input Plugin but since it has some problems I went for MIDI routing for VST3, I already knew about feedback routing but...

...for some reason some tracks works and some other not, I mean that some MIDI tracks is sending midi to VEP and some other is not. This is with the actual version of Reaper, I didn't try with the beta one.

Once it will be in the final stage I'll try it again. Maybe is linked to the VST3 problem I'm already experienced.

So are you guys telling me that for you VST3 main plugin load instantly in the actual release of Reaper?

@DANIELE-ES said:

Reaper DEVS should have recently fixed the slowness of VST3 plugin in a beta version of Reaper as I told in the other thread.

 

To recap, I was already building a template with Event Input Plugin but since it has some problems I went for MIDI routing for VST3, I already knew about feedback routing but...

...for some reason some tracks works and some other not, I mean that some MIDI tracks is sending midi to VEP and some other is not. This is with the actual version of Reaper, I didn't try with the beta one.

Once it will be in the final stage I'll try it again. Maybe is linked to the VST3 problem I'm already experienced.

So are you guys telling me that for you VST3 main plugin load instantly in the actual release of Reaper?

Yeah, I have the current release of REAPER (5.978) and the VST3i plugin loads almost immediately.  I wish I knew more so I could help with what you're experiencing 😞

@DANIELE-ES said:

Reaper DEVS should have recently fixed the slowness of VST3 plugin in a beta version of Reaper as I told in the other thread.

 

To recap, I was already building a template with Event Input Plugin but since it has some problems I went for MIDI routing for VST3, I already knew about feedback routing but...

...for some reason some tracks works and some other not, I mean that some MIDI tracks is sending midi to VEP and some other is not. This is with the actual version of Reaper, I didn't try with the beta one.

Once it will be in the final stage I'll try it again. Maybe is linked to the VST3 problem I'm already experienced.

So are you guys telling me that for you VST3 main plugin load instantly in the actual release of Reaper?

Yeah, I have the current release of REAPER (5.978) and the VST3i plugin loads almost immediately.  I wish I knew more so I could help with what you're experiencing 😞

Well, this is pretty strange because they actually found an issue and fixed it. Maybe it's a matter of configuration but there something effectively missing in VST3 implemetation.

I even tried with a 5.978 clean portable version and had the same issue.

I'm not the only one facing this issue, very very strange. I tried the beta anyway and there it will loads immediately so there shouldn't be a issue on my side...

Anyway until they release the new version with the fix I cannot use VST3i plugin.

@DANIELE-ES said:

Reaper DEVS should have recently fixed the slowness of VST3 plugin in a beta version of Reaper as I told in the other thread.

 

To recap, I was already building a template with Event Input Plugin but since it has some problems I went for MIDI routing for VST3, I already knew about feedback routing but...

...for some reason some tracks works and some other not, I mean that some MIDI tracks is sending midi to VEP and some other is not. This is with the actual version of Reaper, I didn't try with the beta one.

Once it will be in the final stage I'll try it again. Maybe is linked to the VST3 problem I'm already experienced.

So are you guys telling me that for you VST3 main plugin load instantly in the actual release of Reaper?

Yeah, I have the current release of REAPER (5.978) and the VST3i plugin loads almost immediately.  I wish I knew more so I could help with what you're experiencing 😞

Well, this is pretty strange because they actually found an issue and fixed it. Maybe it's a matter of configuration but there something effectively missing in VST3 implemetation.

I even tried with a 5.978 clean portable version and had the same issue.

I'm not the only one facing this issue, very very strange. I tried the beta anyway and there it will loads immediately so there shouldn't be a issue on my side...

Anyway until they release the new version with the fix I cannot use VST3i plugin.

I don't know if this will help, but here are some screencaps of what I think are relevant configurations.  Maybe there's something different about yours that causes issues?  Hope this helps.

Settings 1

Settings 2

@DANIELE-ES said:

Reaper DEVS should have recently fixed the slowness of VST3 plugin in a beta version of Reaper as I told in the other thread.

 

To recap, I was already building a template with Event Input Plugin but since it has some problems I went for MIDI routing for VST3, I already knew about feedback routing but...

...for some reason some tracks works and some other not, I mean that some MIDI tracks is sending midi to VEP and some other is not. This is with the actual version of Reaper, I didn't try with the beta one.

Once it will be in the final stage I'll try it again. Maybe is linked to the VST3 problem I'm already experienced.

So are you guys telling me that for you VST3 main plugin load instantly in the actual release of Reaper?

Yeah, I have the current release of REAPER (5.978) and the VST3i plugin loads almost immediately.  I wish I knew more so I could help with what you're experiencing 😞

Well, this is pretty strange because they actually found an issue and fixed it. Maybe it's a matter of configuration but there something effectively missing in VST3 implemetation.

I even tried with a 5.978 clean portable version and had the same issue.

I'm not the only one facing this issue, very very strange. I tried the beta anyway and there it will loads immediately so there shouldn't be a issue on my side...

Anyway until they release the new version with the fix I cannot use VST3i plugin.

I don't know if this will help, but here are some screencaps of what I think are relevant configurations.  Maybe there's something different about yours that causes issues?  Hope this helps.

Settings 1

Settings 2

I have the same configuration, so is not this. I talked with VSL devs and they said there was a problem with how Reaper is handling VST3. Now. in the beta, it is solved.

I can't really explain this...

@TabbyCat said:

2) On the track on which the VEP plugin is hosted, create Send routings that bus the VEP instance's various outputs to the corresponding MIDI tracks. Example: if a MIDI track sends on MIDI channel 3 to the VEP plugin, and the corresponding instrument in VEP sends its audio output on channels 5/6, route channels 5/6 back to that MIDI track. Also make sure the "Master send" checkbox for the VEP track is unchecked - we only want to hear the audio out of the MIDI tracks.

So I've been experimenting with this and I think I'm missing something.  Can you explain exactly how you set up the kind of Send back to the MIDI channel that you are talking about?  

Specifically, what should I be setting these parameters to?  And are there any other settings I should be aware of.  I feel like there's something I missed when I read the REAPER manual way back...

After messing about with the feedback routing, I found it to be really inconsistent and buggy.  That, or I'm missing something.

Either way, there's another method to route individual MIDI tracks from Ensemble instances to their separate audio tracks (and thus be able to freeze them as stems).  Right click on the Ensemble plugin in the FX chain window and select "Create multichannel stereo outs" (or something like that).  It will automatically create as many properly routed stereo out tracks as the VEP instance has set in its configuration window.  Then, route each channel in VEP7 to the proper out (1/2, 3/4, etc) and the midi will send audio to *that* track.  It increases track count but it seems more reliable to me than the feedback routing method.

@samsonite789 said:

After messing about with the feedback routing, I found it to be really inconsistent and buggy.  That, or I'm missing something.

Either way, there's another method to route individual MIDI tracks from Ensemble instances to their separate audio tracks (and thus be able to freeze them as stems).  Right click on the Ensemble plugin in the FX chain window and select "Create multichannel stereo outs" (or something like that).  It will automatically create as many properly routed stereo out tracks as the VEP instance has set in its configuration window.  Then, route each channel in VEP7 to the proper out (1/2, 3/4, etc) and the midi will send audio to *that* track.  It increases track count but it seems more reliable to me than the feedback routing method.

And here we are, I knew that Feedback Routing has some problems. What's happening to you in details? What issues are you facing?

I simply don't want to double my tracks, I used to work like this in the beginning of my Reaper user experience when I used Kontakt with multiple patches and routed midi channels to it.

Then I started using it with a 1 instrument for 1 instance method to have everything on the same track, now I don't want to revert back to my old usage method, to many things to manage. I have more than 800 tracks, doubling them will result in a total mess.

@samsonite789 said:

After messing about with the feedback routing, I found it to be really inconsistent and buggy. That, or I'm missing something. Either way, there's another method to route individual MIDI tracks from Ensemble instances to their separate audio tracks (and thus be able to freeze them as stems). Right click on the Ensemble plugin in the FX chain window and select "Create multichannel stereo outs" (or something like that). It will automatically create as many properly routed stereo out tracks as the VEP instance has set in its configuration window. Then, route each channel in VEP7 to the proper out (1/2, 3/4, etc) and the midi will send audio to *that* track. It increases track count but it seems more reliable to me than the feedback routing method.

DANIELE-ES,

I figured out what the problem was.  Feedback routing works perfectly.  I was just messing something obvious up; I can be real dense some times.  I'll post a detailed step-by-step guide shortly.

- Sam

Here's how to set up VEP7 with REAPER to do the following:

- Have up to 256 channels of MIDI per instance

- Route the audio so that each track feeding MIDI to the instance is *also* outputting its specific audio. This allows each track to be individually frozen for stem-related purposes.

Thanks to Tabby Cat for the valuable information on how to feedback route.

Step-by-step:

1. Create a track. Place the VST3i plugin of Vienna Ensemble Pro 7 on the track FX rack (MUST be VST3, otherwise it will be limited to 16 channels).
2. Open the plugin interface.
3. Click on this button.
4. Click on this obscure little bastard.
5. Set the following menu opens in the menu that follows: Midi Output, Midi Input (This is to allow REAPER to recognize port settings in VEP7 beyond the first one)
6. Now, build some MIDI tracks by opening the FX Chain window for the track that contains the VEP7 plugin. Right click on the plugin and select the following option. This will create a folder of 16 tracks automatically routing to the instance parent track sequentially from port 1, channel 1 to port 1, channel 16. Repeat this option for as many iterations of 16 tracks as you want to build for this instance. Note that you will have to manually set the port per track send for each track that goes beyond port 1. If there is a faster way to do this, please share!
7. VERY IMPORTANT - Immediately "un-folder" the tracks. If you don't do this, the feedback routing we'll be getting to will get messed up by how REAPER handles folders and signal flow.
8. Set up feedback routing for the project. Normally, that's not a good idea but since we're working with MIDI in, Audio out, it won't result in cataclysmic ear destruction. Go to project settings and check this option on the advanced tab.
9. Be sure to disable "Master track send" on the track with the VEP7 plugin, as we don't want *that* track outputting audio.
10. Now, create a send for each track you're routing back to from the "master track" (the one with the VEP7 plugin on it). Set the audio output of this send so that it matches the audio output set in VEP7. This is starting to get seemingly convoluted, so let's use an example:

• Let's say you have a track that you want to send MIDI data on port 4, channel 4 and then output audio on channels 15/16. Here's what the settings would look like in REAPER and VEP7 respectively:
• Here's the send from the MIDI track
• Here's the send from the "master track" that routes back to the MIDI track
• And here's what the corresponding channel would look like in VEP7

You have to do this individually with each track, but luckily you can save it all as a track template so you only have to do this legwork once.

What you have now is a bunch of tracks that send MIDI data to a "master track" with the VEP7 plugin, which then routes the audio data back to the MIDI track itself. Therefore, if you freeze any of these MIDI tracks, it will only freeze the audio of that specific track and leave the rest of the system untouched. What's more is that you can drag the frozen WAV file out of the track, unfreeze the track, and repeat this process as many times as you want, thus creating different "takes" of stems. Batch freezing works perfectly as well.

I haven't experimented with things like bussing MIR or other FX outputs to different tracks so that you can mix a frozen "dry" track post MIDI, but I'm almost positive this would work without a hitch.

Hopefully, this step-by-step clarifies this process and helps any REAPER users on here get the most out of VEP7! Let me know if I missed anything.

Peace and bunny rabbits,

- Sam

Thank you !!!!!!

It seems to work.

Do you mind sharing what buffer size and soundcard you are using? I have not be able to get my latency down to a rate I'm comfortable using. I run a 2012 maxed out Mac Pro as my sample computer and a 6 core 2013 mac pro as the sequencer with an UAD Apollo quad as my interface. I am away from my 2nd computer for the week but I have had zero luck getting Reaper to play nicely with VEPro. Are you all cutting off the anticipate FX feature?

Thanks for sharing your settings!!

@crd said:

Do you mind sharing what buffer size and soundcard you are using? I have not be able to get my latency down to a rate I'm comfortable using. I run a 2012 maxed out Mac Pro as my sample computer and a 6 core 2013 mac pro as the sequencer with an UAD Apollo quad as my interface. I am away from my 2nd computer for the week but I have had zero luck getting Reaper to play nicely with VEPro. Are you all cutting off the anticipate FX feature?

Thanks for sharing your settings!!

Sure!

Presonus AudioBox USB interface w/ current drivers.  Buffer size is set to 128, and then a setting of "2" in the VEPro plugin.  I do not have Anticipative FX turned off.  VEPro 7 settings are at factory default.  I'm on Windows 10, optimized for audio, quad-core 4.5ghz (OC'ed), 64gb ddr3 ram, single machine.

Hope that helps.  Let me know if there's any more info you need.

- Sam

You are getting much better performance than I am. I will have to take a day to try and trouble shoot what is making my system choke at any buffer less than 1024. Are you able to run large sessions (full orchestra) at 128?

@crd said:

You are getting much better performance than I am. I will have to take a dayto try and trouble shoot what is making my system choke at any buffer less than 1024. Are you able to run large sessions (full orchestra) at 128?

I embarrassing realized that I was trying to run my VEPro through my wifi connection rather than the ethernet cable between my two computers. Now that I fixed that I am getting much better results (duh).

The feedback routing is working well for me, except sometimes the first channel stops sending midi to VEPro if I have an effects send on the channel. Does this happen to anyone else?

@crd said:

I embarrassing realized that I was trying to run my VEPro through my wifi connection rather than the ethernet cable between my two computers. Now that I fixed that I am getting much better results (duh).

The feedback routing is working well for me, except sometimes the first channel stops sending midi to VEPro if I have an effects send on the channel. Does this happen to anyone else?

Another user found a bug with feedback routing.  If you have any of the feedback routing enabled tracks sending to anything else, the first (but only the first) track will not send MIDI if it's *above* the VEPro track in the track control panel.  If this is the case with you, try moving any tracks with VEPro instances to the very top of your project's track list and it should fix the problem.

- Sam

Moving it to the top solved it. Thank you! I am loving the workflow I'm developing with Reaper.