Christian,

Let me just say AMEN to what you are suggesting. You're on a MUCH higher level of technique with this stuff than I am, but I think I'm thinking like you are when I'm using these instruments....it's all about 1 instance per instrument or section, right...!

Two more suggestions. One I have already mentioned in private to Golem, but here is a little reminder.

1) Instruments with no second cell shouldnt react to cell-crossfade. So if I have used cell crossfade one one patch, and change to another I dont have to worry about crossfading back up. As it is now Cell-crossfade causes no sound to be heard because the player crossfades into nothing.

d) Being able to set in/out points in the mapping control diagram. Here is why: Imagine having a velocity crossfaded patch which I want to automaticaly apply some filter to as I cross fade into the highest velocity. I would do this by setting velocity crossfade and filter to the same slider, but invert the filter. So when fading upwards velocity would go up, filter would go down. And heres the problem. When I fade to maximum velocity, the filter will go to minimum filter meaning NO SOUND. So thats why I would be able to set the end point of the filter to 75 rather than 0. So when I crossfade velocity to maximum, the filter goes downward, but ends at 75. A little commplicated to explain, but it should be really simple to implement.

Food for though. Hope you can use it [:)]

I'll just give this a little bump with an appeal to all users to throw your ideas into the open. How do YOU feel the player could be improved?

@Christian Marcussen said:

I'll just give this a little bump with an appeal to all users to throw your ideas into the open. How do YOU feel the player could be improved?

I'd like a feature that suggests a different approach.

So, you play a line, and the VI says "Wasn't this, or a similar line, used in "Terminator 3"? etc, etc. It could save thousands in damage suits.


OK, Ok, seriously though, that's a great idea about cell crossfading. It should know there is nothing to crossfade to...

Tom

The VI automatically selects keyswitches in the 6th octave for bass instruments
It properbly wont matter by the time you can change this since I will have set up my template. But for new users this would be a really niec feature. I can't tell you how tired I am of changing keyswitches from C1 to C6 for my bass instruments. Especially since most my instruments have 12 horizontal cells [[[:)]]]

A varriant of this would be to allow keyswitch selection via keyboard. This would also be really nice. Just doubleclick/rightclick and then press the key on the keyboard.

Drag and drop cells
This was the first change I mentioned months ago. But I just remembered. It would be nice to grab a cell and then just drag it into another cell. So lets say I have set up cells 1-6 with staccato, staccato short, portato etc. and the find out I would like a new patch as the first patch. Then rather than finding each patch again and moving it one cell to the right I could just take the cell and drag it to its neigbour.
----------

Back to creating templates, and finding ideas for improvement [[[:)]]] [H]

Ps: The one I wrote in a previous post about ignoring cell crossfade for instrumemnts with no patch to crossfade to is a really important fix imho [[[:)]]]
Just hoping it isen't overlooked.

Setting XFade Velocity on a local level - i.e. OFF for short notes, ON for legato

This one I'm finding increasingly important. Would be really nice to not have to worry about both switching articulation and turning velocity xFade ON/OFF

I hope this will be considered.

Big vote for drag and drop cells! That would be really handy.

Also want to just be really annoying and mention, in yet another thread, about pushing the "Please wait, loading data..." into the background, so it doesn't take over my entire machine while I'm waiting for samples to load.

I'm sure more stuff will come to mind...

oh yeah! It would be nice to have the standard behavior of "tab" jumping between text fields. I'm thinking of when I change a bunch of keyswtich values; it would be great to just highlight one, enter the new value, then tab to the next one, etc.

J.

Better sample alternating
Having 4 samples of each articulation is great, but could be utillized much better. As it is now (as far as I can tell) samples only alternate after hitting the same note twice in a row. This means that if I play for instance the suspence "theme" from Jaws I keep hearing the same notes.

Solution
Each Cell remembers it's previous position and what sample it played last. So if I hit a staccato note on cell 1, then play some legato and play a staccato note again it plays sample 2.

Parallel Cell On/Off
Pretty much says it all.

Nice with the new software - I see a few of the suggestions have been implemented. Sweet... Unfortunately only some of the minor and cosmetic changes - not the ones that could increase useability 10 fold.

Btw - would it mess things up to do away with the 12 cell h and v limit? I mean, if a user needs 14 why not?

I see you have opned up for a second set of faders for a cell... brilliant.

I have (of course) some suggestions for faders.

A fader which controls the total duration of a sample
Lets say I want a sustain patch but the the hard attack of the sfz. It would be cool If I could stack these two patches but tell the program only to play the first 1 second of the Sfz patch. That way instead of doubling the sound of two when I hold the key, the sfz patch fades out leaving only the sustain patch. Kind of like an automades cell crossfade.

So when the fader is set at 100 it plays 100% of a sample if I hold the key. But if it's set to 20 it will only last 20% of the time, even if I still hold the key.

Transition volume
Controlling the volume of legato transition samples. For instance if I find it too loud in a patch (say the soprano voice patch) I can lower the volume a tad.

Christian, I definitely second your idea about better sampling alternating. Your solution seems like a great one. I'm definitely noticing the same thing you are here with repetions of short sequences of notes....especially in faster passages. One almost starts to hear the "machine gun" effect for short motives. It seems that if Vi simply exausted all of its alternations before returning to the first one...the problem would be solved.

Very good point here Christian.

Best
-Ron

@Christian Marcussen said:

Better sample alternating
Having 4 samples of each articulation is great, but could be utillized much better. As it is now (as far as I can tell) samples only alternate after hitting the same note twice in a row. This means that if I play for instance the suspence "theme" from Jaws I keep hearing the same notes.

Solution
Each Cell remembers it's previous position and what sample it played last. So if I hit a staccato note on cell 1, then play some legato and play a staccato note again it plays sample 2.

I feel really strongly about this feature - so much that I would like to ask for an official comment on it. To me it's a complete no-brainer which would raise the value of all your alterante takes, and therby the useability of the library.

I dont know if its just the kind of music I work on but I wish for this feature daily! I hope its something you can do ASAP!

Any word?

Every cell/key remembers the hit of a certain note but only a certain amount of time after note off of the first hit (1 sec).
So if you go back to a certain key during this period you get the next alternation.
A longer "hold" period would cause conflicts with the sample optimize function, because of random effects starting at different points at your sequenze.

best
Herb

Could a possible solution be to let the user determine how long a period the VI remembers? Users who then do not use the sample optimization feature would then be able to crank it up.