Vienna Symphonic Library Forum
Forum Statistics

200,717 users have contributed to 43,209 threads and 259,123 posts.

In the past 24 hours, we have 3 new thread(s), 9 new post(s) and 61 new user(s).

  1. Home
  2. Sample Libraries
  3. Vienna Instruments Libraries (legacy)
  4. DS - I probably never heard the "Dimension"
  • B
    B

    Beat, this is another response that doesn't meet your criteria, because I don't have time for now, though I'll try to give you what you're asking for later if I get time. In this, I'm sending the same MIDI to all 8 violins, but I'm processing the 8 audio outputs separately, since that's something you can't do with Chamber:

    [url]https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B5ZYXb_HdIQhZkc2UEMtbmNUeVk/edit?usp=sharing[/url]

    It is MIR-free. Nor did I use Altiverb set to Vienna Konzerthaus, since that hall is shaped like a shoebox, and I get the feeling you might not like accurate simulations of shoebox-shaped spaces.
  • V
    V
    Hi again Beat!

    You sound like you are trying not to hurt my feelings or something - well, thanks, first of all :). Second - I understand your need, as a very respectable and long active VSL user to see the justice in DS hype. Now - I own both Chamber and Solo, I love them. I use Hollywood Strings, EWQLSO and love them - so no case of "Oh!- I love it, cause I paid a fortune to get it, and it will be my main thing from now own".

    I am sorry, but I fail to see the "Ferrari" of DS, being the exotic abilities to play differently within an ensemble (fail to see that need altogether, if no divisi lines concerned.) I do love the luxury within DS to shape pretty much any ensemble you want, make them blend well, sound consistent and cohesive, be positioned differently and all, and frankly I cannot justify (for myself) the added workflow of actually playing in 25 takes - I know it can be done for great results, but I don`t see the special need. Workflow is also important for me.

    Not to forget, that DS is much more recent in terms of detail - it sports 4 velocities across most of it articulations - and the legato ones really gain from that, if you are used to the original 2.

    Anyway, I liked your extract, but it is very specific setting, and I can`t help but see it as an orange in apples discussion, with the solos being so upfront. If we would go Chamber head to head with the same amount of DS players - I am definite DS would win, for the reasons mentioned earlier - less interrupted "recorded ensemble" perception, and smoother behavior overall (and I do love Chamber in many ways) By the way, I really don`t like the DS demos from the product page. I bought it relying on my understanding of the great tech and potential - and it never failed me.

    So - I guess I`ll just make a classical mock-up this weekend, to present it both with and without MIR, to show my point, that you don`t have to go exotics with DS to enjoy its qualities.

    Vlad.
  • Beat KaufmannB
    Beat KaufmannB

    Hello again as well, Vlad.

    Thanks for your kind response. Nothing against your favourite library and also nothing against your favourite room and mixing system.

    Keep it, use it, love it.

    All the rest is of course a matter of taste: distant orchestra, close orchestra - unfortunately discussions always end in this never ending "impass".

    About the "Ferrari for shopping": Each articulation seems to come 8times or more with DS (one for each player) in case of the violins.

    But it seems to me that most of the users only use them as one sound. So, having tonnes of samples on board but only using them always as one sound brought me to the comparison with the Ferrari and 30km/h... maybe a bit a daring comparison, sorry, but it probably contains a core of truth.

    Once more: Watch the DS-video please http://www.vsl.co.at/videoplayer_mp4.asp?ID=304. from 04:30...

    Now we changed 1000 words and I didn't get a demo...

    I don't want to discuss about libraries and effects...

    I only hope to listen to a string piece which contains obviously the big advantage of the Dimensions: The individual play of each musician in unison.

    I would like a demo...because I never heard such a piece with the "Dimension" of DS.

    Thanks

    Beat

    - Tips & Tricks while using Samples of VSL.. see at: https://www.beat-kaufmann.com/vitutorials/ - Tutorial "Mixing an Orchestra": https://www.beat-kaufmann.com/mixing-an-orchestra/
  • B
    B
    last edited
    last edited

    @Beat Kaufmann said:

    ... 

    Why do you consider that advantage to be the obviously big one? To me the obvious advantage is the ability to process the audio output from each violin separately. In a different context, you seem to appreciate this advantage:

    [quote=Beat Kaufmann]... I ... want to be free in adjusting the depth for each instrument... to my taste (by mixing the conventional way).

    But as your Chambers don't allow you to do that, you overlook the obvious advantage provided by DS in that respect.
  • Beat KaufmannB
    Beat KaufmannB
    last edited
    last edited

    Hi BachRules

    Thanks for your answers.

    But, dear BachRules, I am since 1975 in the midi business and since 2003 (power) user of VSL samples. So believe me, I know, what I'm looking for...

    @Another User said:

    [quote=Beat Kaufmann]... I ... want to be free in adjusting the depth for each instrument... to my taste (by mixing the conventional way).

    But as your Chambers don't allow you to do that, you overlook the obvious advantage provided by DS in that respect.

    1. I could route every VI to another output within my DAW if necessary... (16 outputs, with my everday AudioInterface / 192 Outputs with my madi system).

    2. You missed the context ... I gave this answer  because I don't want demos "trough" MIR because I love to mix the conventional way and not with an automatic mixing system.

    Unfortuately even more words and even less demos ... sad.

    Once more

    I don't want to discuss libraries, techniques, effects, 

    I only would like to get a DS orchestra demo

    played with the individual trigger mode,

    please, please please!!!

    A link is enough

    This seems to be an unrealizable wish...[:(]

    Sorry my impatience.

    Beat

    - Tips & Tricks while using Samples of VSL.. see at: https://www.beat-kaufmann.com/vitutorials/ - Tutorial "Mixing an Orchestra": https://www.beat-kaufmann.com/mixing-an-orchestra/
  • B
    B
    last edited
    last edited

    @Beat Kaufmann said:

    Can some body publish a DS-Demo ...

    A) ...which shows all 8 violins individual triggered

    Sorry if you already know this, but when you send the same MIDI data to all 8 Dimension violins, each violin gets triggered with different "Humanize" settings. In other words, the time-randomization and tuning randomization are different for each violin. That could be considered "individual triggering", depending on semantics.
  • A
    A

    It seems odd that no one seems to have grasped what Beat is asking for here,

    One of the first things I did with Dimension strings, was to play the same thing eight times, each to a dimension player. It is a long winded way of doing things,  but that is how a real orchestra play, so it seemed to me the best way to do it.

    How ever it did take a long time to do this, and when you do a similar thing with playing once and using VI Pro to randomize timing for each player, it also gets close to the same effect.

    My recording unfortuanaley for Beat,  was processed through MIR, so I can't offer a dry demo either, 

    but I do think Beat's request for a dry multi played layer demo is a reasonable request.
  • B
    B
    last edited
    last edited

    @Beat Kaufmann said:

    ... I ... want to be free in adjusting the depth for each instrument... to my taste (by mixing the conventional way).

    But as your Chambers don't allow you to do that, you overlook the obvious advantage provided by DS in that respect.

    1. I could route every VI to another output within my DAW if necessary... (16 outputs, with my everday AudioInterface / 192 Outputs with my madi system).

    You're talking about routing VI's separately, but I'm talking about routing violins separately. I can put the 8 Dimension violins in different positions in a virtual room (not MIR, since you don't want that), and they all reflect off the walls at different times, since they're in different positions, and the left and right mics in a virtual Decca-tree capture the sounds at different times. You cannot do this with Chamber, even if you route your VI's separately.
  • B
    B
    last edited
    last edited

    @andyjh said:

    It seems odd that no one seems to have grasped what Beat is asking for here,

    I grasp it, but haven't found the time to meet his demands. This thread is still pretty new. I'm not so pessimistic that Beat's demands won't be met eventually.
  • Beat KaufmannB
    Beat KaufmannB
    last edited
    last edited

    @BachRules said:

    You cannot do this with Chamber, even if you route your VI's separately.

    OK then, my dear, let's listen to such an orchestra with individual placed players. 

    Take A/B, ORTF, a DeccaTree, NOS, DIN, EBS, Surroound...  for me only counts the result.

    I want to come as close as possible to those real recordings. And I thought that the DS could go a step further. 

    But all the Demos don't show a really step foreward. Quite the oposit, I don't like the sound (MIR?) and when the are syncronized the sound not realy how an ensemble.

    But I'm repeating my self - words words words but obviously no demo.

    - Tips & Tricks while using Samples of VSL.. see at: https://www.beat-kaufmann.com/vitutorials/ - Tutorial "Mixing an Orchestra": https://www.beat-kaufmann.com/mixing-an-orchestra/
  • Beat KaufmannB
    Beat KaufmannB
    last edited
    last edited

    @andyjh said:

    How ever it did take a long time to do this, and when you do a similar thing with playing once and using VI Pro to randomize timing for each player, it also gets close to the same effect.

    Hi Andy

    This is really a good hint.

    Even if I am a trained user I still need 1day for 1 minute of music (average).

    So this means that I will use a lot more time for eventually a bit more reality.

    Thanks, and yes it seems that nobody had the patience to produce a piece which obviously uses a much more effort.

    Best

    Beat

    - Tips & Tricks while using Samples of VSL.. see at: https://www.beat-kaufmann.com/vitutorials/ - Tutorial "Mixing an Orchestra": https://www.beat-kaufmann.com/mixing-an-orchestra/
  • B
    B
    last edited
    last edited

    @Another User said:

    when you send the same MIDI data to all 8 Dimension violins, each violin gets triggered with different "Humanize" settings. In other words, the time-randomization and tuning randomization are different for each violin. That could be considered "individual triggering"....
    As a result of this feature, even if I send the same MIDI to all 8 violins, I will never get the same sound twice, because each time the timing and tuning will be randomized in a different way. Of course this is not an option with Chamber, as the violins in that ensemble have their timings and tunings locked together in the samples.
  • T
    T

    Greetings,

    I share Beat's position on DS, and would like to hear a demo which depicts clearly the aforementioned aspects of the product. Most demos I found worked in disservice for DS, because I believe they were made with the intention of showcasing its overall sound. However, more experienced users usually expect a technical demonstration, and I think that is lacking in sound form. 
  • B
    B
    last edited
    last edited

    @Beat Kaufmann said:

    ... Can some body publish a DS-Demo ...

    A) ...which shows all 8 violins individual triggered or even played with individual articulations?

    Can you recommend any particular pieces where Bach scored 8 different articulations for 8 violins playing in unison? If I understand your request correctly? If not Bach, then Beethoven?
  • H
    H
    last edited
    last edited

    @Tralen said:

    Greetings,

    I share Beat's position on DS, and would like to hear a demo which depicts clearly the aforementioned aspects of the product. Most demos I found worked in disservice for DS, because I believe they were made with the intention of showcasing its overall sound. However, more experienced users usually expect a technical demonstration, and I think that is lacking in sound form. 

    Hi Tralen,

    maybe this video is helpful for you. (the part from TC 4:20 to 5:30)

    http://www.vsl.co.at/videoplayer_mp4.asp?ID=304

    best

    Herb
  • Beat KaufmannB
    Beat KaufmannB
    last edited
    last edited

    @BachRules said:

    Can you recommend any particular pieces where Bach scored 8 different articulations

    No restrictions. Bach, Mozart, Haydn what ever... 

    Beat

    - Tips & Tricks while using Samples of VSL.. see at: https://www.beat-kaufmann.com/vitutorials/ - Tutorial "Mixing an Orchestra": https://www.beat-kaufmann.com/mixing-an-orchestra/
  • B
    B
    [quote=Beat Kaufmann]

    I'm not about to make anything that sounds close to that, and few here are, regardless of their choice of libraries; and you already knew that. So I'm not going to try to compare to that, but if you want to post a short, simple example of Chamber violins (or some other Chamber instrument, but just one, please), sticking to one and only one articulation, I'll try to make a DS version of what you post. Otherwise, it's going to be a question of who's better at programming articulations, which seems irrelevant for all present intents and purposes.
  • Beat KaufmannB
    Beat KaufmannB

    Dear Bachrules, thanks a lot for your great help for me to get a DS demo.

    The thread here shows that obviously even power users don't use this "multiple-option" because it seems to need a lot of additional work.

    So your effort is very kind, BachRules, and you all who wanted to help me till now. But, nobody should produce an extra demo for me.

    So I suggest to wait until the end of this weekend and when nobody has a demo - then nobody has one.

    Could be that G. Bacos will produce once one one - now with the basses inclusive.

    I still believe in a huge undiscovered potential of DS - showed within some seconds in the DS-Video...

    So let us being patient ...

    Beat

    - Tips & Tricks while using Samples of VSL.. see at: https://www.beat-kaufmann.com/vitutorials/ - Tutorial "Mixing an Orchestra": https://www.beat-kaufmann.com/mixing-an-orchestra/
  • B
    B
    last edited
    last edited

    @Beat Kaufmann said:

    Dear Bachrules, thanks a lot for your great help for me to get a DS demo.

    The thread here shows that obviously even power users don't use this "multiple-option" because it seems to need a lot of additional work.

    So your effort is very kind, BachRules, and you all who wanted to help me till now. But, nobody should produce an extra demo for me.

    So I suggest to wait until the end of this weekend and when nobody has a demo - then nobody has one.

    Could be that G. Bacos will produce once one one - now with the basses inclusive.

    I still believe in a huge undiscovered potential of DS - showed within some seconds in the DS-Video...

    So let us being patient ...

    Beat

    This thread shows that people lacking Dimension Cellos -- even power-users / articulation-extremists lacking Dimension Cellos -- are unable to achieve such a wide cello sound as this:

    [url]https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B5ZYXb_HdIQhVEFEdXE2UVRnbTg/edit?usp=sharing[/url]

    Maybe Beat can produce something comparable with the Chamber Cellos. Let's wait until the end of this weekend and if nobody achieves such width using only Chamber Cellos - then nobody achieves it. I'll wait patiently.
  • J
    J
    last edited
    last edited

    @Beat Kaufmann said:

    But, dear BachRules, I am since 1975 in the midi business
    That's pretty amazing, since the MIDI specification was published in 1983. BTW, MY main use for DS is divisi as flexible as a real orchestra. A piece I just completed has 48 separate parts. Sometimes every instrument has a different note, sometimes they're doubled, tripled, etc. Much more realistic than using the same 1 or 2 solo instrumets over and over, and virtally no phasing problems.