Hello Steve

Just a little suggestion (joke):

Let the singers breathe a breath from time to time... in December...  ;-)

Hi Beat,

thanks for taking the time to listen. Yes, It would be a good idea if I did give them a chance to breathe!

best,

Steve [:D]

Steve,

This is indeed very nice - love the piano arrangement. I knew Beat was going to chime in on the breathing, as that is a sticking point with him (and he's right).

As I was listening, I kept thinking you should scrap the voices altogether and bring in VSL's solo cello instead. With the piano accompaniment you've written, that would sound fabulous.

At any rate, keep writing! You're doing well.

Corte

Hi Corte,

thank you for your feedback and it's nice to know that you like the arrangement. Sorry, I should have explained though, that this is for an actual performance for a Xmas CD that I am being employed to write the arrangements for, so there is a soprano soloist, and there is also going to be a part written for a tenor soloist also and they will be singing above the piano part for the recording. I  suppose what some people would call this is a "midi mockup", so if I was using the Soprano choir for a mockup, I would definitely have to put in some breathing space for them. I was just playing along with my piano track and playing the Soprano VI without actually thinking about putting spaces for breathing in there.

I am thinking though, that your suggestion would be a good idea for another version of the piece.  I do have the full version of the VSL solo strings also.

Thanks again for your comments and feedback Corte.

best,

Steve[:D]

 Hello Steve,

every time I listen to the intro I hear snow gently falling...

Good luck with your work,

Sebastian

Hi Sebastian,

thank you for the encouraging feedback.  I'm glad it stimulates your imagination to come up with a scene like that!'

best,

steve [:)]

Great composition and piano playing. One of my favorite traditional Christmas hymnals. Thanks for sharing... 

Thank you Jake for the positive feedback. Glad you enjoyed the music.

best.

Steve[:)]

 Steve

Your arrangement of Silent Night sounds great and I would like to hear the final version.

For what its worth here are some comments:

don't over complicate the piece - over arangement can destroy the serene simplicity of the piece;

re change of key for last verse " don't do it"  Bach, Mozart and Beethoven would never do it;

 Boy Bands  do it  - as they stand up and walk towards the camera - and  it is absolutely "mince" - that is a  light hearted Scottish saying for  "rubbish"

Regards

Kanon

Hi Kanon,

thank you for your reply and advice. I also had someone else tell me not to do a key change at the end either, so with your advice also reinforcing the same thing, I have decided not to do the key change. I'm aiming to keep this as simple as possible. For the recording, it will only be two voices, a soprano and tenor, and I will be adding some very light strings, and a few other very light instrumental colours. That is where it is going to be a challenge - to not overdo it.

thanks again for your comment and feedback. I do appreciate that!

best regards,

Steve[:D]

Hi  Steve

your arrangment was interesting and since we're approaching Christmas i thought if you have an updated or even a final version to share? i would like to hear that :)

Hi Mayyar,

sorry, I have no update for the file, as there are other things I have been working on.However, I would like to do another version, but, I don't know if I will get it done before xmas though due to other things taking my time unfortunately.

If I do manage to get another version done, I will post the new file for you to listen to.[:)]

Thanks and best,

Steve [:)]

Hi Saxer,

thank you for listening and the feedback. If you are curious, I can let you know what the chords are. Ffrom my memory,  the first one  isa d minor over b minor, with the melody note in the right hand moving down in semitones, [a half diminished type harmony over a B], and the second chord folowing that is a F minor over an E in the bass, which then moves to an A minor chord next, and to a D major 7th chord with a melodic minor harmonies over the top.

Thanks again for the positive feedback. I'll be getting around to orchestrating this soon for the CD.

best,

Steve.

Hello Steve

I  listened to your arrangment days ago for more than once, and i wanted to tell you that i appreciate it a lot more than wheni first heard it, i don't know why, but i just realized the workk you've put in it, i loved it, it is GOOD!! i loved the harmony!

Hi Mayyar,

thank you kindly for the feedback. I do appreciate that you enjoyed the music.

best,

Steve[:D]