@Another User said:

Maybe part of this stems from my frustrations with using Logic itself, which after several years I still find to be a thoroughly unpleasant experience.

Well, this same principle applies strongly to Logic. I got Logic at v2.x (!! waaaay back) and it took me a long time to get a handle on what the hell was actually going on. I became quite comfortable after a while, and my understanding of Logic grew through v3, v4 etc to v7.x which I now use.

God help the poor souls who come upon Logic now!! It's so huge that it's scary and there are some functions which I have still hardly ever or never used.

Getting back on point: There was never a manual from Emagic that gave a beginner a simple "Start here - now do this - okay, then do this" type of initiation into the arcane and secret world inside the program. There were manuals, but they were simply long explanations of all the buttons and functions. You'd literally have to read through hundreds of pages before you could understand the environment and how to connect all your MIDI gear, before you could record a note!

So, this is what users want, but don't always get - a walkthrough manual of how to get started, then how to go deeper and so on.

Anyway I hope the VSL team hear us. . . .

Regards - Colin

PS - don't give up on Logic, give it another 5 or 6 years and you should be fine! [H]

Hello,

I agree very much.
What I miss in most manuals is this very direct approach like: e.g. you want to record a sequence in Logic 7. To do this click here, click there, now look at this window, and so on until you see a recorded sequence.
I don't want to know how everything works in the beginning, I just want to record something into my computer, and I want a clear path to reach this goal. Of course you cannot cover everything this way, and there should be something more elaborate also, but for basic things it would be very nice not to have to read so much before you can do something seemingly simple. I am a composer, not a technician.

Greetings,

Gerard

JWL, thanks you so much for your words on how it could be better explained for simple people like us.
The "look how simple it is !…" isn't always shared by people with a different logical mind.

Your idea of taking a non VSL member seems very good.

This is what Roland did with their S770 sampler.

Roland had been known for having almost useless manuals, in broken English and needlessly complex all around. So with what was then their new flagship sampler, they hired Paul Lehrman to write it. It made the whole learning process wonderful. It was conversational, and since Paul plays, it was practical.

Here's hoping....

Tom

Lord knows I have had it up to here with manuals written in "Japanglish."

I was just at the Synful site and I appreciate that they have their manual in .pdf format. In addition, their demos presented on their website are available for examination in different sequencer formats when you download the program:


• Mac OSX. Go to Macintosh HD/Applications/Synful/Synful Orchestra/Examples. .lso is for Apple Logic, .dpf files are Digital Performer, cpr for Cubase, and .mid for simple Midi.

• Windows. Go to /Program Files/Synful/Synful Orchestra/Examples. .cpr is for Cubase, .cwp for Sonar, and .mid for simple Midi.


I imagine that Synful is targeting many of the same people that the VSL folks are; hopefully we can see some of the same for the new VI stuff. For people like Steve ("there's still time - $100 reward" thread) who have to resort to offering strangers money so he can learn this way it seems rather silly that VSL hasn't stepped up to the plate to offer some demo sequences to help people see the big picture.

Clark

@clarkcontrol said:

I imagine that Synful is targeting many of the same people that the VSL folks are; hopefully we can see some of the same for the new VI stuff. For people like Steve ("there's still time - $100 reward" thread) who have to resort to offering strangers money so he can learn this way it seems rather silly that VSL hasn't stepped up to the plate to offer some demo sequences to help people see the big picture.

Clark

I'm not too worried yet, as I haven't even caught a sniff of VI (and won't for another month). However, I do remember that there were tutorials and demo files available for Pro Edition and (Perf. Set) which were very useful, so I would hope that VSL is going to continue down this road. As we actually have a chap on this forum whose signature is "VSL Manuals" I would like to hope that all our concerns are already being taken care of [:D]

DG

That would be our David Ender.

DG,

Yes, true we haven't even seen the product yet. It's easy to forget that amidst all this excitement.

Something I forgot to add to this .pdf manual thing: In many of these digitized manuals one has the ability to use hypertext to zoom around the manual, do searches, connect to the web, etc.

In other words, it's not just a xeroxed paper manual.

Dietz mentions David Ender. I have seen him post quite a few times and the guy really has me believing that the new manual(s) are going to be excellent.

Anyway, VSL has everything to gain by making available a .pdf version freely downloadable for anyone to check out--and this would also apply to their quicktime videos, IMHO. I know that people like me get serious gear lust by pouring through these things, whether it is for Synful, Soundsoap Pro, a new laser printer or the Exsmanager. It's better and cheaper than an add campaign.

Clark

@Another User said:

JWL, thanks you so much for your words on how it could be better explained for simple people like us.
The "look how simple it is !…" isn't always shared by people with a different logical mind.

Your idea of taking a non VSL member seems very good.

Cheers, Laurent!

As I mentioned earlier, having seen more of the videos, I already feel more confident that VI will be much more intuitive than PE- for me, anyway. I'm always fascinated about how other people learn a new application from scratch without taking a formal training course. I just believe that having a pdf to print out or even having a proper manual will make it a lot easier and faster to have this wonderful musical tool work for me rather than me working for it.

"I was a BIG user of the S760 (and still use it!!). It took forever to figure that thing out, and the manual was notorious for having one sentence on an otherwise blank page that said nothing more than-- "In this window you may edit the sample.". That was the entire chapter on that particular feature. There was no indication how to get to that window or what the abbreviated symbols and buttons meant. "

Right. That's why I said "Roland 770". The Roland 770 manual was written by Lehrman, and was great. When they came out with the 760, the went back to doing the manual themselves, and it was, again, awful....[;)]

TH

@clarkcontrol said:

Dietz mentions David Ender. I have seen him post quite a few times and the guy really has me believing that the new manual(s) are going to be excellent.

Don't give me too much credit yet, or I'll never be able to live up to it! [[;)]] Anyway, I try to do my best and hope you'll find it useful. After all, Vienna Instruments was completely new to me, too, not so long ago. But you couldn't have the manuals be written by someone who's never worked with a sequencer or sampler before, or you'd get your VIs in half a year's time at the earliest.

In any case, I'll keep working on the manual and adapt it when I find from your comments that there's something missing or misunderstandably explained, and manual updates will be published on the VSL user area. If you don't feel the necessity to discuss some issues in the forum, you can also send me comments and propositions by e-mail: d.ender@vsl.co.at.

Regards,
David

Cool, thanks, we really appreciate.

@clarkcontrol said:

Dietz mentions David Ender. I have seen him post quite a few times and the guy really has me believing that the new manual(s) are going to be excellent.

Don't give me too much credit yet, or I'll never be able to live up to it! [[;)]] Anyway, I try to do my best and hope you'll find it useful. After all, Vienna Instruments was completely new to me, too, not so long ago. But you couldn't have the manuals be written by someone who's never worked with a sequencer or sampler before, or you'd get your VIs in half a year's time at the earliest.

In any case, I'll keep working on the manual and adapt it when I find from your comments that there's something missing or misunderstandably explained, and manual updates will be published on the VSL user area. If you don't feel the necessity to discuss some issues in the forum, you can also send me comments and propositions by e-mail: d.ender@vsl.co.at.

Regards,
David

Hi Dave--

Thanks so much!!

The idea was not to have someone who has never used a sequencer-- just someone who has never used VI (like all of us here). As long as you are the new pupil of VI, then following YOUR learning process will be the most edifying information we can get.

Please don't underestimate how important that is or how much what you are doing for us is deeply appreciated and highly valued.