Vienna Symphonic Library Forum
Forum Statistics

194,056 users have contributed to 42,907 threads and 257,904 posts.

In the past 24 hours, we have 3 new thread(s), 19 new post(s) and 96 new user(s).

  • Using reverb and pan to create the correct instrument positions.

    Hi, I'm totally new to VI and have just bought the Special Edition - very impressed!

    I am trying to set up my orchestra so that the instruments are in the right place on the stereo field (pan), but am having difficulty making the distances right (i assume I should use reverb).  I assume that this is probably been discussed at length in the forums but couldn't find anything.

    My set up is:

    Logic 6

    Space Designer (plus other reverbs)

    I have tried things such as giving every instrument a different reverb through a single bus, as well as giving instruments their own reverb before going through the 'room reverb' bus.

    Any suggestions?

    Guy


  • Hi

    I've purchased the Special Edition a few days ago too.
    I've just built a small starting-template including reverb, panning etc. and by doing that I noticed, that EQing is VERY important to get a proper feeling of distance for some instruments.

    Especially the woodwinds need a strong low-cut (to make em sounding less heavy and big) and even a little bit less of their highs (e.g. a little bit damping of the blowing noises).

    Another important thing for Solo Instruments in general is, to make em totally or almost mono.


  • Hi Guy,

    I would check out the Christian Kardeis demos in the video tutorial section of the website.

    http://vsl.co.at/en/68/375/381/456.vsl

    I do agree that EQing is important, however, how much, what instruments, and what frequencies you EQ depends a lot on what reverb you use, and how much of the sound you are sending to that reverb.  Christian's demos showed me how important dry sounds are to the overall mix, and how dry can effect distance.  Personally I've found that I like putting reverb on a bus rather than on each instrument, using only two busses, 1 bus for near sounds, 1 bus for far sounds.  Obviously strings and ww's would go near, brass and percussion would go far (except some perc. needs extra attention, see the videos).  Depending on what reverb and how you use it, I think any more than two (maybe three) reverbs starts to make things too muddy. 

    Though everyone has an opinion about what is the best way to EQ/reverb/etc. with VSL the advice they (and myself included) give is from the perspective of their own setups and their own ears, which is probably not like yours.  You must trust your ears and if possible share some of your work with the great people on this forum, they can help a lot.

    However your ears can be deceiving when left to their own devices.  To solve this problem I would recommend finding some good orchestral recordings (recordings you think sound really great) of solo and ensemble passages, and listen to them very carefully.  This way you have a bar to measure you setup against, analyze every aspect of them and see if you can get your VSL setup close enough to those recordings that you can play along with them and it sounds like your VSL instruments are part of the recording.  Remember that your not trying to make your VSL setup sound like a real orchestra.  You trying to get it to sound like a RECORDING of a real orchestra.  Whether you get there or not is not as important as making the attempt.  You will learn so much from the attempt.  I think this is a good way to start, but after this I would do some mock-ups of pieces you really like that you have good recordings for.  This is invaluable because you will have a very specific sonic goal to aim for that will not only improve your template, but teach you how to solve certain performance problems with VSL using patches in ways that may not be obvious from the get go.

    In general, short, controlled experiments are the best way to learn at first.  Experiment on specific problems like clear woodwind solos, getting brass punch, getting a full string sound thats close yet rich in filling up the room., etc.  It will be more productive if you don't try to tackle too many things in any one experiment.  Hope this all makes sense.

    Good Luck!  Brian [:)] 


  • Oh one more thing, rather than pan, use some sort of stereo imager.  VE offers "power panning" for free, but Waves S1 Stereo Imager seems to get used by people a lot as well.

    Also, see this thread, http://community.vsl.co.at/forums/t/17895.aspx as it might give you some ideas on how dry also effects placement in the stereo image. Dietz seems very knowledgeable about these matters.

    Brian 


  • Cheers for the reply - what exactly do you mean by make solo instruments almost totally mono?


  • last edited
    last edited
    Brian, thanks for your response - I think I shall take up your idea and try and emulate one of the recordings I have. I have tried to use VE as the pan control did look good but I cannot get past the AU validation (I have no idea what the instructions are on about and none of the screens they talk about come up). I tend to agree with another users I came across in the forums that VI/VE instructions leave a lot to be desired! On that note, do you (or anybody else out there) know of any instructions that are specific to using VI/VE in logic?

    I got quite a lot out of the demo videos and in particular the downloadable track. It was great to see the processes and analyse them. On that note, do you (or anybody else) have a piece/setup that you would be willing to email me (guybunce@hotmail.com) for me to check out? I would of course reciprocate by emailing my latest work?

    Thanks once again for your help.