Hi Christof,
I'm certainly not responding to your post to speak on behalf of Paul H. Smith, but I do want to mention something about the Wii Remote in regards to what you said, because you use VSL and think its an outstanding tool. I agree with you! However, as we all know VSL does not work all on its own. In addition to VSL you need a computer, audio output, speakers (or at least headphones), a sequencer (if you want to hear more parts than you can play yourself), and I think most people use some sort of midi keyboard. I like to call these things as a whole the INTERFACE. The interface between you (the human) and the vibrations in the air that hit your ears. Your instrument is an interface, language is an interface, some might even argue that our body is an interface. I think its fair to say, the more understanding, control, and sensitivity a person develops with an interface the more likely we are to call that person talented. Even if the results they produce on that interface may appear displeasing to or may not be understood by some, the fact remains that they can produce and replicate those results many times over when others on the same interface can not. It still means that particular person is talented. I'm getting a little off track here, but the point is that humans want desperately to be expressive and want other people to feel that expression.
However, there is always an interface between those two boundaries, and it has to be reckoned with if communication/expression is going to take place. Now we've all accepted the computer/digital interfaces between our musical desires and the results coming out of the speakers. Some of us are better than others at that interface, because they've discovered how to translate their expressiveness through the interface. Most of the time this has to be learned though hours of experimentation and practice. However, there are some things the body (because its an interface that is closer connected to the brain) is just naturally more expressive at than our digital interfaces. As a musician I'm sure you can relate to that! I believe conducting is one of those things.
I don't know about you, but if I could conduct in my tempo maps rather than draw them in by hand, I would jump at the opportunity because I know I can be more expressive with my body in that way, than by drawing with my mouse on the computer. I think the Wii Remote has the potential to let more of the humanness into our digital music worlds because it relies on body motion. Notice I say potential, but I think Paul H. Smith is seeing that potential and doing some really good experiments to make our sampled music more expressive. So I don't look at it as trying to replace real musicians, but the Wii is just further developments in human digital interfaces. Lots of great stuff! Ok I'll stop now as I think I've gone on probably a little to much. [:D]
Brian