A big issue here will be how many articulations you want to load at any given time. It seems like you may want to keep everything in midi and bounce at the last minute in case any last minute curves are thrown. That's the way I work too and, after a few curves, thankfully so. the problem quickly becomes having enough articulations available so you don't have to bounce. With a library the size of VSL, I anticipated a mac for the sequencer and kontakt, with the bulk of the VSL samples on two giga machines. That was QUICKLY saturated and I went with another giga machine which got me to a point where I was happy. Many others are happy with less so it really pays to think it through as you appear to be doing.

Can't really help with Logic as i use Digital Performer. I would imagine the overloads are similar in either application which symptomatically suggests more of a cpu rather than ram issue. I run a G5 dual 2.0 and altiverb, kontakt and lots of other au instruments with no problem. Where ram becomes more of and isse is with samples. if you're thinking of Logic/EXS, then you will need a ton of it which has probably been discussed in detail in the exs forum if you need more info.

hang in there!

Ok, but knowing what I want (lots of simultanious instruments) if I add lot of RAM to either the G5 dual 2.7 or the upcoming "dual-core", can I be guaranteed that I won't have saturation problems? Talking about 100 simutanious tracks. If I'm going to spend over $2000. of additional memory I'd want to be sure it's going to work.

@Guy said:

If I'm going to spend over $2000. of additional memory I'd want to be sure it's going to work.

$2000? Where's that come from. Check here.

http://www.crucial.com/store/listparts.asp?Mfr%2BProductline=Apple%2BPower+Mac&mfr=Apple&tabid=CR&model=Power+Mac+G5+%28Dual+2.7GHz+DDR%29&submit=Go

Guy, if you want 100+ tracks, you may need to consider a more robust solution. I'm not sure 1 computer can tackle all of your needs...

I keep about 120-130 articulations loaded at a single time. I'd like more but the law of diminishing returns kicks in. So if articulations in my setup roughly correspond to tracks in yours, it doesn't seem that a single computer is going to get it all done as everything here (G5/G4 powerbook and 3 Giga machines) is full to the hilt. the only thing I cant comment on is how logic and exs might change that. maybe someone else can chime in on that.

@Guy said:

If I'm going to spend over $2000. of additional memory I'd want to be sure it's going to work.

$2000? Where's that come from. Check here.

http://www.crucial.com/store/listparts.asp?Mfr%2BProductline=Apple%2BPower+Mac&mfr=Apple&tabid=CR&model=Power+Mac+G5+%28Dual+2.7GHz+DDR%29&submit=Go

Hi PolarBear,

For me, add canadian tax and convert to canadian dollars=over $600. 2Gb

6 GB= $1800. approx.

Once again this is to find a solution to avoid using 2 computers, but nobody yet has written that a single computer will do what I'm looking for.
100 tracks+....

It's possible to have 100+ tracks on a sequencer machine, but not to load the needed articulations to do that in the same machine at once. No-go as of today, neither with Mac nor with PC. But well, you don't loose money on buying only one G5 today and add another G5 or a PC at a later point (just a small shipment fee).

Are you buying registered or unregistered RAM modules? $600US looks heavy, 2GB should cost around $200US... Some more Mac-savvy please chime in here but afaik the max that will be of use for you would be 4.5GB with Logic and EXS (and around 3.5GB of that useable for samples then).

Oh and, you quoted PaulR, not me [;)]

PolarBear

Ok, I'm becoming less ignorant by the post. But since I want to not wait too long before making my purchase and be sure to buy the needed hardware, I'd like some realistic advice for a proposed budget. This is what I was use to: G5, Logic and VSL. But now I want to buy the Complete Orchestral Package and I have no sound card. My budget is $15,000.CD tops.let's: $13,000 USD, (stupid canadian dollar!) For the moment I'd rather stick to one computer but have it working well enough to not give me TOO much trouble with saturation problems. If I could reach 80 or 90 tracks live, that will be pretty good for the moment. I would really appreciate some suggestions giving me basic specification on what to order or buy in that budget. G5 dual 2.7? new dual core? Ram? Soundcard?etc.

Guy

@Guy said:

Ok, I'm becoming less ignorant by the post. But since I want to not wait too long before making my purchase and be sure to buy the needed hardware, I'd like some realistic advice for a proposed budget. This is what I was use to: G5, Logic and VSL. But now I want to buy the Complete Orchestral Package and I have no sound card. My budget is $15,000.CD tops.let's: $13,000 USD, (stupid canadian dollar!) For the moment I'd rather stick to one computer but have it working well enough to not give me TOO much trouble with saturation problems. If I could reach 80 or 90 tracks live, that will be pretty good for the moment. I would really appreciate some suggestions giving me basic specification on what to order or buy in that budget. G5 dual 2.7? new dual core? Ram? Soundcard?etc.

Guy

Just one more thing to confuse you. If you a certain that you are going to do everything on one computer then it might be worth converting your solo samples into mono as that should save RAM. This way you will be able to get more instruments and articulations at a time, assuming that your Mac is fast enough to cope with all this.

DG

Okay! Okay! Okay! You've convinced me, there's no way aroud using 2 computers/gigastudio for my needs. I'll have to take your word for it, I doubt my paperboy will know about this... BUT if I start with my initial idea, 1 computer and as powerful as possible I could always add gigastudio any time, right? And all I'd have to do is buy a PC (any specification for the PC?)
and make the connections, right? Is this complicated to manage or install?

@Guy said:

BUT if I start with my initial idea, 1 computer and as powerful as possible I could always add gigastudio any time, right? And all I'd have to do is buy a PC (any specification for the PC?)
and make the connections, right? Is this complicated to manage or install?

Why would you want to do that though Guy?

Why waste time with Gigastudio if you're going to get a G5 2.7 with loads of ram? That's starting to get unnecessarily complicated to me.

And why GS - why not say, Kompact?

@Guy said:

Okay! Okay! Okay! You've convinced me, there's no way aroud using 2 computers/gigastudio for my needs. I'll have to take your word for it, I doubt my paperboy will know about this... BUT if I start with my initial idea, 1 computer and as powerful as possible I could always add gigastudio any time, right? And all I'd have to do is buy a PC (any specification for the PC?)
and make the connections, right? Is this complicated to manage or install?

Of course you can add as many PCs to your system at any time you like. The only extra potential expense is that you will also need a sound card and of course GS itself, but once you have that you can get site licences for additional PCs. Then, of course, you will need to buy a side licence for VSL, as I doubt that the conversions will work too well due to the complexities of VSL mapping. However, if you're not intending to use any of the Performance instruments GS might just do the conversions adequately.

GS is not complicated to install, and as long as your PC is set up only to run it you shouldn't have problems.

DG

@PaulR said:

And why GS - why not say, Kompact?

I assume that you mean Kontakt; Kompact is a different beast from the same zoo [:D]

The downside to K2 is that the Pro Edition is not available, so for Perf instruments one has to do conversions.

DG

Thanks Paul.

Because nobody yet told me that with loads of RAM I will be okay. If only one person could testify to that I wouldn't hesitate, but I have no guarantee that it will work fine, maybe it won't be able to process it fast enough... Would you know for a fact that I'll be able to easily manipulate 80, 90 or 100 tracks all in RAM? That's really my concern. Many people have said that using 2 computers is the solution. But maybe with the dual 2.7 it will be different, I don't know...

And do you think I should wait for the new dual-core, will that make a big difference?

Just to add: I will be using lots of performance instruments and pleny of articulations.

Thanks again guys, very helpful [:D]

Guy

@DG said:

I assume that you mean Kontakt; Kompact is a different beast from the same zoo [:D]
The downside to K2 is that the Pro Edition is not available, so for Perf instruments one has to do conversions.
DG

Yep - brain fart on my part right there Daryl. [:O]ops:

@Guy said:

Thanks Paul.

Because nobody yet told me that with loads of RAM I will be okay. If only one person could testify to that I wouldn't hesitate, but I have no guarantee that it will work fine, maybe it won't be able to process it fast enough... Would you know for a fact that I'll be able to easily manipulate 80, 90 or 100 tracks all in RAM? That's really my concern. Many people have said that using 2 computers is the solution. But maybe with the dual 2.7 it will be different, I don't know...

And do you think I should wait for the new dual-core, will that make a big difference?

Just to add: I will be using lots of performance instruments and pleny of articulations.
Guy

Actually, a forum pal of mine emailed me from America yesterday with this very question. Hmmmm. That's a difficult one.

Nick Batzdorf is the guy who really helps me when I'm in trouble over this stuff, because like you, I am a computer moron and too lazy to get to grips with the technical side of things - because like you, I had a guy who did all this for me. So, like you, I now have to learn all this from scratch in some ways, which is a royal pain.

My 2 cents at the moment would be Guy - if you are in a hurry and can't wait, I would maybe go for a 2.7 with as much ram as you can afford (but see later at the bottom) - things may change when Logic is updated and can see roughly more than 3.4 gigs - BUT - this may only be applicable to Logic, when Apple bring out the new sort of hybrid processors maybe sometime next year - maybe. [[;)]]

Another good pal on this forum, Strawinsky was telling me the other day he was going to get the new duel core that is due out imminently - I forget how many Macs he has at the present. [:D]

Guarantees is word I've tried to avoid most of my life - but I would imagine you will want to build a large template. A lot of the members do this I know - like Evan Evans for example - but 80 to 90 instruments? I don't know about that. I don't ever use a template personally, maybe I should, but I don't get hung up about reality and articulations as much as the others- maybe I should.

I would wait for the duel core if it was me and not in that much of a hurry - but maybe the other guys can jump in of they read this.

Well, I'm hearing good things about the new dual core, good thing I still haven't bought my computer yet, I'm pretty much set on it now.

Template. [:D] I think it's something you eat.

Template! [*-)] No, it's a car model.

Template? [:O]ops: Maybe it's a plant...

Template #!@%?? [:'(] It's not a fast tempo?

OK! What is it? [8o|]

Preconfigured setup with the most needed articulations and your tracks ready to load. Just to save you time on choosing those patches and be ready to compose once you booted.

I suspected it was something like that. Thanks.

My recommendation I'll try to not confuse you like some of the other posts confused me... youre question was simple enough how do I go about buying all this stuff...

Obviiously you want a mac (good on you...)

the 2.7 is the way to go, don't get a slower machine than that, 4.5 gigs is plenty - they come with 2X256 RAM sticks, buy another 4X1gig sticks. Later, you can ditch or sell the 2X256 sticks, and buy another 4X1gig sticks. The reason for this, Logic will probably be updated to access a lot more ram in the near future, I'm guessing in the next 12 months. For now, 3.5-7 gigs is actually the tops as has been stated, however, if you have a external SATA RAID system, with about 4 fast drives (at least 7200 RPM) you can set you virtual memory in EXS to use more drive swapping than RAM, increasing then number of samples you have in memory. Also, you can freeze tracks if you use a RAID system of another 2 or 4 drives you should be able to freeze at least 64 stereo tracks for play back, plus have around another 64 stereo EXS instruments running in realtime, for a total of 128 stereo EXS tracks. If you freeze an instrument that you are not altering particularly a legato performance instrument, it unloads the sample from memory and just reads the audio file from disk - very handy. What this means is that you can do a lot with just a single system, and personally I just have one system for samples and sequencing and it works great and my system is only a 2.0ghz not a 2.7 so you should have no problems running all that. Bear in mind with the dual core: 1. you can buy the exisitng machine cheaper when the dual core is release, 2. there will probably be reliability issues in the first 3-6 months with a new processor with a very different design - does anybody know if they will be able to make use of the dual core with logic straight away or will that require an update?

As for purchasing, I recommend you go to 3 different music shops, and give them your list of the things you want, G5, Logic Pro extra ram, raid systems and say what's your price for this. Choose the one that gives you the best price AND service and seem like they know what they are doing and do this kind of thing all the time. With the raid system, do some good research into what is good can't help you there I don't have that yet.

Miklos.