Vienna Symphonic Library Forum
Forum Statistics

196,068 users have contributed to 43,014 threads and 258,388 posts.

In the past 24 hours, we have 2 new thread(s), 16 new post(s) and 153 new user(s).

  • last edited
    last edited

    @Leon Willett said:

    Evan,

    The epitome of excitement actually came when he said that he made a very cool trumpet sample with you! While I'm in Carmel next year beating your french horn secrets out of you, I'll raid your hard drive too. [:D]

    Leon
    He he. Yeah, that trumpet is ME. Probably is in every thing Scott does. What's cool about it is how real and warm it sounds. Certainly not that it's a great trumpet sample. it's only like 1.3MB. But it's every note and the attacks are to die for (they're me!).

    Anytime, you wanna come up to visit you are welcome. Also I give advanced film music composition lessons.

    Cheers,
    Evan Evans

  • I too was there this weekend. I can't tell you how much I recommend it. To have a chance to hear from a guy like him who's been in the industry for 25 years is priceless. He has changed not only the traditional approach to orchestration but he also challenged standard practice. His thinking is very practical and everything he says makes total sense. (okay the alien technology is quite challenging! [:P])

    I had to catch my flight right after the class last night so I could not take up his extended invitation to go hang out at his house on the mountain. Thankfully I had the opportunity to get to know him a bit better over a few beers the night before. Still I'm pumped, bring on that 20 staff manuscript paper.

    Rock on dude!

    =m=a=r=c=

  • last edited
    last edited

    @Leon Willett said:

    Hi guys,

    Another awe-inspiring spear of knowledge is that you don't have to use only II-V-I's when you write music. You can use chords that move by thirds, like Gerry Goldsmith. He states how this realisation changed his life for ever. There is no further explanation.



    Leon


    hey all,
    leon's frustration bought back a great part of the class for me.
    during the course, i was in the same class as fred story in ny, this II-V-I and progressions in 3rd parts was very interesting. The larger context was about writing cues that sound like they're progressing but not resolving. Throwing in V-I relationships tend to slow down the forward movement in the cue. it's great for stacking 4 bar and 8 bar phrases in song form but not enhancing a long and gory battle between the forces of good and evil or a torrid love scene. scott referenced off the II-V-I in the context of the history of movie and tv scores--alot of the composers from the 60's and 70's were jazz cats who wanted to settle down, so they went to LA. II-V-I's
    were rampant. One of scotts personal battles was to help these guys expand their pallet of colors. He personally fought off composers dogmas in the trenches off hollywood, so when he mentions moving away from II-V-I's or other techniques, it not a tip or a trick or rule it's a personal victroy. scott personaly lead the conversion from transposed scores to concert scores in hollywood. so when he mentions using concert scores it not just an obvious tid bit, it's his history.

    Does everyone who takes his course sound like a member of a cult? Hail the mighty scott!!!! How dare you question the devine knowledge?!?
    sorry about the tone. I'm gonna have to learn how to use the smiley faces.

    Often scott just gets unharmonized lines and instument indications for a cue that emotionally goes all over the map. By progressing in major or minor 3rds (throw in a minor chord when you need dark and major chord when you need bright) you get great color change and drama but don't have to work so hard avoiding tonic resolutions which can slow the pace down. if one had 7 french horn attacks to accompany parts of a building blowing up that leads to a chase scene, it's a great technique. no where to go but forward. smally applied this technique when harmonizing the main batman theme.....a very successful theme.
    a short five note english horn theme (i love the vsl english horn) played while someone is going through a dresser and is afriad they might find body parts(which is the least of this persons problem because the audience can see the killer is watching her from the closet and quitetly muttering "no mother, no") might be harmonized like this...Cmin to Abmin to Emin to Bbmin to Dmaj. The major chord is for when she finds a picture of herself as a child, the E to Bb is just a matter of skipping over a possible G root.
    to help the chords flow a bit use an independent bass line. ...Cmin/Eb to Abmin/Eb to Emin to Bbmin/F to Dmaj/F#. Scott showed examples of how alan silvestri uses this technique (with the seperate bass lines) to the point of obsession.
    These colors are no secret, you can hear them all over, from Giant Steps to Forest Gump. One of Smallys points was, when you get the cue from the composer at 10:58PM and the down beat for the recording session is at 8AM the next morning, speed and sysetems will get you through the night in a less fickel manor than inspiration.


    sorry about the long post it's lunch time and it's too cold to leave the damn building.
    James

  • [...

  • Very Interesting James. It makes sense. I really have to catch his next one in SLC [:(]

    Rob

  • last edited
    last edited

    @PaulR said:

    [quote:5b02cced95="see why what?"] One of Smallys points was, when you get the cue from the composer at 10:58PM and the down beat for the recording session is at 8AM the next morning, speed and sysetems will get you through the night in a less fickel manor than inspiration.

    James



    James, you're kidding, of course.[/quote]

    paul,

    Kidding about inspiration being tempermental or the inhospitable time frame?
    the time frame is common and inspiration is a poor collaborator.
    :>[;)] (still haven't figured out the smiley faces)
    james

  • last edited
    last edited

    @PaulR said:

    James, you're kidding, of course.
    Kidding about what? Nothing he said was kidding. What are talking about Paul?

    Evan Evans

  • [...

  • [quote:4a049a50f0="see why what?"]a short five note english horn theme (i love the vsl english horn) played while someone is going through a dresser and is afriad they might find body parts(which is the least of this persons problem because the audience can see the killer is watching her from the closet and quitetly muttering "no mother, no") might be harmonized like this...Cmin to Abmin to Emin to Bbmin to Dmaj. The major chord is for when she finds a picture of herself as a child, the E to Bb is just a matter of skipping over a possible G root.[/quote]

    The E to Bb is also a diminished 5th, which is the 'wild card' interval in the whole Mediant Harmonic concept. (Or 'Goldsmithian Technology' as Scott likes to call it.)

    Like the three chords in the "Batman" main theme melody...Cmin, Ab, Dmaj. Third, diminished 5th. Big and dramatic.

    Fred Story

  • COOL! [:D]

  • last edited
    last edited

    @PaulR said:

    James, you're kidding, of course.
    Kidding about what? Nothing he said was kidding. What are talking about Paul?

    Evan Evans

    Sorry lads! My bad. I misunderstood the use of the word 'speed' [:O]ops:

    i went over that part of my post to figure out how one could possibly find 2 meanings in what i wrote....laughed my arse off! [:D]
    ...it inspired me to figure out how to use the smiley faces.
    james

  • [...

  • Ohhhhhhhhhhhhh LOL!!!!!

    Now I get it. Although to be honest, Scott does say that Excedrin gives him a Caffiene boost in the wee hours when the crunch its really on.

    Evan Evans

  • ...

  • The Mr. Smalley we hung out with would have laughed his butt off.

  • james, fine explanation (of the II-V-I > 3rds evolution, not the sp--d)
    [:)]
    thanks

    Nigel

  • oh god, Scott would have been laughing in tears at that Paul. You would have been officially accepted into his "clan".

    [;)]

    Evan Evans

  • Moving chords in thirds has been around a couple centuries guys so I'm not quite seeing a big bright light on that one (and yes in a non diatonic manner.) In the last century it's preponderance is abundant.

    Any other nuggets to be put forward?

    Dave Connor

  • ...

  • Hi Paul!

    Okay, chords are built in thirds. If you wanna build a chord where C is the root, you need an E and a G too. You can keep on adding thirds if you want, but three notes is enough for it to be considered a chord.

    In any given key, you can build 7 different chords, just by stacking thirds above each of the 7 notes in the scale. If you study harmony, each of these chords is given a roman numeral I II III IV V VI VII, for simplicity.

    So, in C major, chord I is C E G. Chord II is D F A. Chord V is G B D. So, in answer to your question, a II-V-I is a progression of chords. You can play a II-V-I in any key, and it will have the same emotional effect. Each chord has an emotional effect (refered to as "function"). For instance, chord I has an effect of resting, of comming home. Chord V has the most tension, and "wants" to go to I. The extent to which I'm simplifying is ridiculous, but what the hell.

    Anyway, if you play a II V I using seventh chords (four notes per chord, like C E G B), you will realise it's the staple diet of the jazz language. Well, beebop anyway. It's really boring! I share Scotts boredom with II-V-I.

    Now, if you look at the relationship between those three chords, the roots are at a distance of a descending fifth. (D G C) This is a kinda boring relationship, because we have heard it too much. Scott suggests moving arround by thirds instead, like I-III, or I-VI. The magic starts to happen when you start forgetting about being in a particular key, and giving the chords you move to the "wrong" attributes. Tradditionally, chord II (DFA) is minor. Well, make it major if you like [:)] .

    So, the concept (which I agree, has been around for about a century and is old news), is to move by thirds, and use whatever kind of chord you like. You are never really in any particular key, and you never get that crappy V-I stark feeling of resolution. Oh, it's also very "Elfman" to move the roots by a tritone (C to F#).

    Leon