Vienna Symphonic Library Forum
Forum Statistics

192,762 users have contributed to 42,853 threads and 257,641 posts.

In the past 24 hours, we have 3 new thread(s), 19 new post(s) and 167 new user(s).

  1. Home
  2. Software
  3. Vienna Instruments Pro
  4. VE Pro 5 Audio/Event Input in DP
  • K
    K

    I'm talking about DP8. The guys at MOTU were made aware of the issue and solved it. It was not really a bug in DP7 as such. More like DP7 not being ready for the way the VE Pro 5 Audio/Event Input plugins work. Nobody is to blame in the matter but the changes in DP8 fixed the issues with bouncing and latency compensation with regards to VE Pro.

    EDIT: I was a bit premature in my conclusions about bouncing. It only happened to work in my one test session, but I can't get it to work again now. Apologies. 
  • A
    A

    Thank you Karel for your infos! It's finally time to upgradeee!!!!

    DP7 to DP8 and VEP4 to VEP5
  • W
    W
    last edited
    last edited

    @Karel said:

    So far I haven't found any problems with VE Pro 5 and DP8. And indeed, bouncing with the Audio/Event Input plugin seems to work flawlessly. Mind that all affected tracks (VE Pro Server Interface plugin track, its assigned VE Pro Audio/Event Input plugin tracks and their respective audio/MIDI tracks) need to be selected or bouncing will indeed just result in silence. It is still required to set the Audio Plug-ins preferences to All Plug-ins in Real-time for proper functionality, much like with DP7. All in all a rather major improvement.

    Karel, unfortunately I am not getting the same results. I've followed your instructions above, but - while I can get a perfect MIDI bounce with midi tracks assigned to the 16 channels of the VE Pro Server Interface plugin track - the midi tracks assigned to a VE Pro Audio/Event Input plugin track just yeild an audio bounce that has a handful of erratic notes playing. BTW, this is all with Kontakt 5 plugins. Any thoughts?
  • K
    K

    I'm very sorry, but it seems I was a bit premature in my conclusions about bouncing. It only happened to work in my one test session, but I can't get it to work again now. I'll try to find out what made it work that one time, but it doesn't look too promising at this point. My sincerest apologies for any false hope I may have given you.
  • F
    F

    Thanks Karel - we all greatly appreciate your efforts on our behalf
  • L
    L
    I'll second that Karel
  • S
    S
    Knowing the bounce problem, I did a Freeze Tracks instead, selecting the entire short sequence, and I got some gargled sounds on two of the eight stereo tracks I froze. Freezing one at a time produced good results. So I don't know if things got worse with DP8. This is on VE5, but I didn't use any event inputs. Will do some more tests once (if) I survive my current deadline. Anyway, hope things gets worked out soon.
  • A
    A
    last edited
    last edited

    @Karel said:

    I'm very sorry, but it seems I was a bit premature in my conclusions about bouncing. It only happened to work in my one test session, but I can't get it to work again now. I'll try to find out what made it work that one time, but it doesn't look too promising at this point. My sincerest apologies for any false hope I may have given you.

    Hi Karel,

    any news on this subject? I've got my DP8 upgrade copy on my shelf waiting to be installed (still on DP 7.24/VEPRO 4). Then I'd like to upgrade to VEPRO5, hopefully knowing that "bounce to disk" is going to work just fine sometime in the near future. Am I being too optimistic? 😉

    Cheers

    Arceo
  • K
    K

    Bounce to disk works equally fine in VE Pro 5 as it does in VE Pro 4. It's just the new additional Audio/Event Input plugins (that come with VE Pro 5) that will not bounce correctly. So there is no real reason to not upgrade to VE Pro 5.
  • F
    F

    Hi - for what it's worth and just bin case it helps - it looks like DP8 is a one way upgrade and you can't easily go back to DP7 if it doesn't work out.  There are some issues with DP8 which will be resolved in the 8.1 update according to a friend who spoke to MOTU yesterday.  Quite aside from the bounce to disk thing, I am staying with DP 7 until the first update.  The other option some people have done is to put DP8 and a OS on a separate drive to test.  I have no problems with VSL5 inside DP7 but I don't use the event input bounce to disk thing anyway at the moment. 
  • A
    A
    last edited
    last edited

    Thank you Karel for pointing that out. Anyway I'd like to know if there has been any progress in the "Event Plugin/Bounce to Disk" issue.

    Your last words on ther subject were

    @Karel said:

    I'll try to find out what made it work that one time, but it doesn't look too promising at this point.

    Can you please tell whether there any hope for us DP users to take advantage of Event Plugin while having all the DP's features fully working or this is (and will always be) a trade off to deal with, in order to achieve the sample accurate synchronization that DP 7,24/VEPRO 4 never achieved and DP8/VEPRO 5 achieved (as far as I know from reading the previous posts)?

    Thank you Flashman for sharing your experience.

    Re DP8 quirks, I know what are you talking about. I'm constantly readings other user's experience at Motunation and so far there are some bugs that are a no go for me and my personal workflow. Me too I'm waiting for a .01 bug release to upgrade.
  • K
    K

    It's unlikely that this bounce issue (which, I emphasise, only happens when using the Event/Audio Input plugins) will be fixed anytime soon. However VE Pro 5 works just the same way as VE Pro 4. You don't have to use the Event/Audio Input plugins if you don't want to and your projects will just open as before. Everything works just as well (and better) than with VE Pro 4. Just to make clear that VE Pro 5 is not worse than VE Pro 4 in DP in any way.
  • B
    B
    I've set the number of ports to 16, restarted VE PRO5 I can see them set plugin to receive to them but when I go to DP8 and add the event plugin it shows only 8 ports. Then I go back to VE PRO and it shows 8 ports only! I go back in the pref and still says 6 ports. Is that a DP limitation or bug?
  • A
    A

    Hi Karel, I'm late to this conversation but am all too familiar with the issue. I had a similar experience as you with Bounce to Disk where when I tested DP8 with a large template using the Event Processor - and it worked fine, then it stopped working correctly - notes would bunch together in odd ways - and then it stopped working entirely.

    I know I can freeze and bounce, but my template is 150 or more midi tracks, and my music can be as long as 5 minutes. Freeze/bounce takes too long under a tight television deadline, and I have resorted to bussing the VEPro plugin to an audio track.

    I am on the latest releases of DP and VEPro and it won't Bounce to Disk. Is there any hope for a fix? 

    Thanks,

    Robert
  • A
    A
    last edited
    last edited

    @Anthropy said:

    Hi Karel, I'm late to this conversation but am all too familiar with the issue. I had a similar experience as you with Bounce to Disk where when I tested DP8 with a large template using the Event Processor - and it worked fine, then it stopped working correctly - notes would bunch together in odd ways - and then it stopped working entirely.

    I know I can freeze and bounce, but my template is 150 or more midi tracks, and my music can be as long as 5 minutes. Freeze/bounce takes too long under a tight television deadline, and I have resorted to bussing the VEPro plugin to an audio track.

    I am on the latest releases of DP and VEPro and it won't Bounce to Disk. Is there any hope for a fix? 

    Thanks,

    Robert

    +1

    Hi Karel, the Release Notes for the new DP update (8.0.5) clarly states:

    "Improved compatibility with Vienna Symphonic Library (VSL) and Vienna Ensemble Pro (VEP)."

    So, is there a chance that Event Plugin/Bounce to Disk issues has been addressed?

    TIA

    Arceo
  • A
    A

    It is not working correctly -

    I can confirm that on my system, only midi that is sent through the server plugin will bounce, no Event Processor midi gets bounced. Just before I updated VEPro to 5.2.12800 (Oct. 8, 2013) I was able to bounce to disk using the same template as today's test. After downloading and installing the latest VEPro, I could no longer bounce tracks that use the Event Processor.

    Here is my system:

    MacPro 2 x 2.26 Quad Xeon, Snow Leopard 10.6.8, 16GB RAM

    Digital Performer 8.05 in 64bit mode, VEPro 5.2.12800 in 64bit mode, Kontakt 4, Vienna Instruments 5.3.11859

    Incidentally, freezing tracks is not an option as my VEPro/Event plugins are on a V-Rack.

    Regards,

    Robert
  • A
    A

    Karel?
  • K
    K

    There have been no changes to the VE Pro plugins and their network protocol for quite some time. The Audio/Event Input plugin not being able to bounce is an inherent limitation from the way the DP audio engine works, so the feature should be used at own risk, knowing that offline bouncing is impossible. This is something we cannot change on our side, and we can't expect the DP developers to change the way their engine works either, as it is most likely a non-trivial exception to make.
  • A
    A

    Sounds like the U.S. Congress.

    It worked beautifully for a while - then I upgraded something - pretty sure it was VEPro, but it may have been something else - and it broke.

    Motu's user base is made up largely of film composers like me, so maybe they'll address the issue. If it all gets working it would be an unbeatable combination - DP/VEPro.

    Has any more thought been given to an MAS version?
  • K
    K

    We've checked out the MAS SDK a bit, but it is a rather huge undertaking to support it. Perhaps something for a future version, but no promises...