Vienna Symphonic Library Forum
Forum Statistics

186,187 users have contributed to 42,445 threads and 255,760 posts.

In the past 24 hours, we have 4 new thread(s), 16 new post(s) and 44 new user(s).

  • Velocity curves of CFX and Steinway are different - is it normal?

    Hi!

    If I play same midifile on CFX and Steinway with same settings, Steinway sounds like a velocity values is +20 - is it normal?

    Best regards,
    Vadim


  • Yes, I must say I notice this too, and several users over at PianoWorld have also commented on it.  One of them suggested that the likely cause is the very different sampling techniques used, with the CFX sampled using the built-in facility, while the Steinway was sampled using the robot.

    Regardless, it is slightly curious that it was not normalised in some way prior to release.  It suggests that VSL regard the velocity curves/midi sensitivity of the two as broadly equivalent, but it's hard to see how.  The Steinway sounds almost brutally harsh on a linear velocity curve and zero midi sensitivity.


  • At all, a velocity curve editor/presets in SY Piano Player is very appreciated!


  • But don't make it so huge, like the controller curves in the SYPlayer. Otherwise people could accidentally read values or set proper x-over points... ;)